Calls Grow To Remove Christopher Columbus Statue and Rename Columbus Circle

NBC New York3 minutes read

Approximately 150 protesters marched to Wall Street, using red paint to symbolize police violence while advocating for the removal of the Columbus statue, which is linked to slavery and violence against Native Americans, gaining 4,000 petition signatures for its renaming. Governor Andrew Cuomo defended the statue for its representation of Italian-American contributions, noting that efforts to address historical injustices have been ongoing since a 2017 commission recommended retaining the statue with added historical context.

Insights

  • Protesters in New York City demonstrated against police violence by marching to Wall Street and symbolically dropping red paint on Fifth Avenue, while also calling for the removal of the Christopher Columbus statue, which has been criticized for its ties to slavery and violence against Native Americans; a petition to rename Columbus Circle has quickly gained around 4,000 signatures, reflecting growing public sentiment on the issue.
  • Governor Andrew Cuomo defended the Columbus statue as a representation of Italian-American heritage, acknowledging the impact of the Black Lives Matter movement on raising awareness about justice for minorities; he noted that a commission established by Mayor Bill DeBlasio in 2017 recommended keeping the statue but adding a plaque to recognize historical wrongs, alongside future plans for a statue honoring Indigenous peoples.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • What is police violence?

    Police violence refers to the use of excessive force by law enforcement officers against individuals, often resulting in physical harm or death. This issue has gained significant attention in recent years, particularly in the context of protests advocating for racial justice and police reform. The term encompasses a range of actions, including physical assaults, shootings, and other forms of brutality that disproportionately affect marginalized communities. The growing awareness of police violence has sparked widespread calls for accountability, changes in policing practices, and a reevaluation of the systemic issues that contribute to such violence.

  • Why are statues controversial?

    Statues can be controversial due to their representation of historical figures whose actions and legacies are viewed differently by various groups. Many statues commemorate individuals who played significant roles in history, but some of these figures are associated with oppressive actions, such as slavery, colonialism, or violence against marginalized communities. As societal values evolve, the public's perception of these figures can shift, leading to debates about whether to remove, replace, or contextualize these monuments. The controversy often centers around issues of historical memory, identity, and the impact of these figures on contemporary society, prompting discussions about how to honor history while acknowledging its complexities.

  • What does a petition do?

    A petition is a formal request or appeal made to an authority, often signed by a group of individuals, seeking a specific action or change. Petitions are commonly used in advocacy efforts to demonstrate public support for a cause, such as changing laws, removing controversial symbols, or addressing social issues. The process typically involves gathering signatures from supporters, which can help to amplify the message and pressure decision-makers to respond. Petitions can be an effective tool for grassroots movements, as they mobilize community engagement and raise awareness about important issues, ultimately aiming to influence policy or public opinion.

  • What is the Black Lives Matter movement?

    The Black Lives Matter movement is a social and political movement that seeks to address systemic racism and violence against Black individuals, particularly in the context of police brutality. Founded in 2013, the movement gained prominence following high-profile incidents of police violence, sparking widespread protests and calls for justice. Black Lives Matter advocates for policy changes, accountability for law enforcement, and broader societal recognition of the injustices faced by Black communities. The movement emphasizes the importance of intersectionality, highlighting how issues of race, class, and gender intersect in the fight for equality and justice.

  • What is the significance of Columbus statues?

    Columbus statues are significant as they represent the historical legacy of Christopher Columbus, who is often credited with "discovering" America. However, his actions also involved violence and oppression against Indigenous peoples, leading to a complex and contentious legacy. Supporters of the statues argue that they honor Italian-American heritage and contributions to the United States, while opponents contend that they glorify a figure associated with colonialism and genocide. The debate surrounding these statues reflects broader discussions about how societies choose to commemorate history, the need for inclusive narratives, and the importance of recognizing the impact of historical figures on marginalized communities.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Protests Erupt Over Columbus Statue Controversy

  • Approximately 150 protesters marched from the Upper West Side to Wall Street, dropping red paint on Fifth Avenue to symbolize bloodshed from police violence, while calls intensified to remove the Christopher Columbus statue at Columbus Circle due to his involvement in slavery and violence against Native Americans; a petition to rename Columbus Circle has garnered around 4,000 signatures since its launch four days ago.
  • Governor Andrew Cuomo defended the statue, asserting it represents significant Italian-American contributions to the country, and highlighted that the Black Lives Matter movement has amplified the fight for justice for minorities; in 2017, Mayor Bill DeBlasio initiated a commission to review controversial statues, which in 2018 recommended retaining the Columbus statue but adding a plaque to acknowledge historical atrocities, with plans for a statue honoring Indigenous people to be erected in the future.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.