Are the Priestess Girls Really THAT Boring?? (Examining Values Dissonance in Persona)
LadyVirgilia・7 minutes read
Japanese Persona characters like Fuka, Yukiko, and Makoto may be perceived as boring in more extroverted societies due to differences in cultural values, despite being popular in Japan.
Insights
- Yosuke and Ryuji are more popular globally than in Japan, while Fuka, Yukiko, and Makoto face varying levels of popularity due to cultural differences.
- The disparity in character popularity across regions highlights the impact of cultural values on audience perceptions, with introverted traits being viewed differently in Japanese and Western societies.
Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free
Recent questions
Why are some Persona characters more popular in Japan than globally?
Some Persona characters like Yosuke and Ryuji have differing popularity between Japanese and Global audiences due to values dissonance. Japanese culture values introverted traits, which can lead to characters like Fuka, Yukiko, and Makoto being perceived as boring in more extroverted societies.
Which Persona characters are less popular in the West compared to Japan?
The Priestess girls, Fuka and Yukiko, are less popular in the West compared to Japan. This difference in popularity can be attributed to cultural values and perceptions of introverted traits in different societies.
Why is Makoto, a fan favorite overseas, still perceived as boring by some?
Makoto, a fan favorite overseas, is still perceived as boring and spineless by some due to differences in cultural values. Japanese culture values introverted traits, which may not resonate as well with more extroverted societies.
What is the main reason for the differing opinions on Persona characters between Japanese and global audiences?
The main reason for the differing opinions on Persona characters between Japanese and global audiences is values dissonance. Japanese culture values introverted traits, which can lead to characters like Fuka, Yukiko, and Makoto being perceived differently in more extroverted societies.
How does Japanese culture influence the perception of Persona characters in different societies?
Japanese culture influences the perception of Persona characters in different societies by valuing introverted traits. This can lead to characters like Fuka, Yukiko, and Makoto being seen as boring in more extroverted societies, contributing to differences in popularity between Japanese and global audiences.
Related videos
LadyVirgilia
Why is Yosuke #1 in Japan while Ryuji & Kanji are... not even close? (Values Dissonance in Persona)
JohneAwesome
MY PERSONA HOT TAKES
LadyVirgilia
The Truth About Ann Takamaki (Character Analysis in Japanese Context)
LadyVirgilia
What do the Arcana even mean? (P5R Main Cast Confidant Analysis, aka Part 1 of 2)
Fither
Every Persona Character Ranked By Popularity
Summary
00:00
"Persona Characters' Popularity Reflects Cultural Values"
- Persona characters like Yosuke and Ryuji have differing popularity between Japanese and Global audiences.
- The Priestess girls, Fuka and Yukiko, are less popular in the West compared to Japan.
- Makoto, a fan favorite overseas, is still perceived as boring and spineless by some.
- Differences in opinion stem from values dissonance between Japanese culture and others.
- Japanese culture values introverted traits, leading to perceptions of characters like Fuka, Yukiko, and Makoto as boring in more extroverted societies.
