30 Black Peter from The Return of Sherlock Holmes (1905) Audiobook

Sherlock Holmes Stories Magpie Audio2 minutes read

Sherlock Holmes investigates the murder of Captain Peter Carey, uncovering clues like a bloodied notebook and a missing securities box, leading to the arrest of the true killer, Patrick Cairns, through meticulous deduction and reasoning. Holmes solves the case, securing Cairns' confession and ensuring justice is served, proving his superior investigative skills over Inspector Hopkins.

Insights

  • Holmes' investigation into the murder of Captain Peter Carey revealed a complex motive involving missing securities and a connection to a scandal, shifting initial theories on the case.
  • The true murderer, Patrick Cairns, was identified through Holmes' deduction based on clues like his seafaring background, strength, and possession of a tobacco pouch, showcasing the depth of Holmes' investigative prowess and attention to detail.

Get key ideas from YouTube videos. It’s free

Recent questions

  • Who is Sherlock Holmes?

    A detective known for solving complex cases.

  • What was the focus of Captain Peter Carey's murder investigation?

    The investigation centered on a harpoon engraved with the ship's name.

  • How did Holmes solve the case of Captain Peter Carey's murder?

    Holmes deduced Patrick Cairns as the true murderer.

  • What was the significance of the initials JHN and CPR in the investigation?

    The initials hinted at a deeper connection to the crime.

  • How did Holmes assist in resolving the case successfully?

    Holmes provided crucial insights and assistance in capturing the murderer.

Related videos

Summary

00:00

Sherlock Holmes Solves Black Peter Murder

  • In the year 1895, Sherlock Holmes was at the peak of his fame and practice, often helping humble clients over wealthy ones.
  • Holmes was engrossed in a series of diverse cases, from investigating the death of Cardinal Tosca to arresting Wilson, a notorious canary trainer.
  • The focus shifted to the mysterious death of Captain Peter Carey, known as Black Peter, a dangerous and loathed man in his community.
  • Holmes, with his unique methods, delved into the investigation of Carey's murder, discovering the gruesome scene in Carey's cabin.
  • The murder weapon, a harpoon engraved with the ship's name, indicated a crime of passion, possibly involving an appointment between Carey and the murderer.
  • Various objects in the room, like a tobacco pouch and a notebook with stock exchange securities, hinted at potential motives and the presence of a second person.
  • The notebook's initials, JHN and CPR, intrigued Holmes and Hopkins, suggesting a deeper connection to the crime and a possible motive.
  • Hopkins realized the significance of the initials, potentially leading to the identification of the second person involved in the murder.
  • The introduction of the document with valuable securities provided a motive for the crime, altering Holmes's initial theories on the case.
  • The investigation into Captain Carey's murder took a new turn with the discovery of the notebook, pointing towards a complex and intriguing motive behind the crime.

16:50

Murdered Man's Notebook: Holmes Solves Case

  • Holmes is examining a notebook with a bloodstain, indicating it was dropped after a crime.
  • The notebook belongs to a murdered man, Mr. Carey, and none of his securities have been found.
  • A sheath knife near Mr. Carey's body is identified by his wife.
  • Holmes decides to visit the crime scene in Forest Row with Inspector Hopkins and Dr. Watson.
  • They find a cabin where the murder occurred, and someone has tampered with the lock and window.
  • Holmes suspects a potential burglar who may return with better tools.
  • They wait in ambush and catch a young man, John Nelligan, trying to access logbooks related to his father's scandal.
  • Nelligan explains his father's disappearance after being accused of fraud, linking it to Mr. Carey's involvement.
  • Nelligan sought the logbooks to clear his father's name but found crucial pages missing.
  • Hopkins arrests Nelligan, and Holmes reflects on the case, expressing disappointment in Hopkins' investigative methods.

33:35

Holmes Solves Murder Mystery with Cairns

  • Holmes receives several letters at Baker Street, excitedly instructs Watson to send telegraph messages to Sumner Shipping Agent and Inspector Stanley Hopkins.
  • Holmes plans to resolve a case that has troubled him for 10 days, determined to banish it from his presence.
  • Inspector Stanley Hopkins arrives for breakfast, discussing a case with Holmes, convinced of his solution's correctness.
  • Holmes questions the feasibility of Hopkins' solution, highlighting the impossibility of an anemic youth committing a violent assault.
  • Holmes reveals Patrick Cairns as the true murderer of Peter Carey, stunning Hopkins with his deduction.
  • Cairns confesses to killing Carey due to a past incident involving a mysterious man on a ship, leading to a confrontation and murder.
  • Holmes deduces Cairns' identity as a seaman based on various clues, including his strength, harpoon skills, and tobacco pouch.
  • Holmes explains his investigative process to Hopkins, detailing how he traced Cairns through research and devised a plan to capture him.
  • Holmes advises Hopkins to release young Neligan and return the tin box to him, acknowledging the lost securities.
  • Holmes offers to assist in the trial, providing his and Watson's address in Norway, concluding the case successfully.
Channel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatarChannel avatar

Try it yourself — It’s free.